Treating Customers Like Family

Committed to Meeting Our Customers’ Needs
Our Products & ServicesContact Us Today

We Wood Love to Help You

High-Quality Products, Excellent Customer Service

Add value to your investment when you choose Wagner Lumber & Supply for your construction and home-improvement materials. Our store in Rensselaer, IN, stocks a wide range of products designed to make your project a success. Our mission is to provide both high-quality products and excellent customer service through problem-solving, innovation, and continuous improvement. Customers have come to rely on us for our skill, knowledge, and commitment to ensuring their 100% satisfaction.

Get to Know Us

Dustan Wagner purchased Wood Bros Seed & Lumber in Rensselaer, IN, in June 2016. The store had been established for many years and had much success in meeting customers’ needs. However, the owners were ready to retire, and Dustan was eager to take over and grow the business. He renamed the shop Wagner Lumber & Supply and has continued to carry on the store’s tradition of guaranteeing customer satisfaction. Dustan and his associate put forth their best effort on every sale and project, and their skills and knowledge complement each other well.

We are family-owned and operated, and we live and work in the area so we treat each customer like family. Our store is recognized throughout our community for our support of many teams, organizations, and causes. This year we started a scholarship/award for seniors graduating from our local high school.

Your Guaranteed Satisfaction

Our services include sales of all types of high-quality building materials, job-site delivery, construction advice, and free quotes and estimates. If any problems arise, we will resolve them quickly at no expense to our customers. We know that time is money in this industry. We stand by our work and take full accountability.

Wagner Lumber Supply in Rensselaer, IN

Contact Information

Phone: 219-866-5832


801 N McKinley Ave Rensselaer, IN 47978


Monday – Friday
7:00 AM – 4:30 PM
7:00 AM – 12:00 PM